Suggestions: "Case studies", "Available funding", "Solar power and renewables"

Case Studies

Case Studies

Mareeba Hay Farm

Energy Savings: 113%   |   Cost Savings: $9,800   |   Capital Cost: $43,500   |   CO2 Savings: 57.6   |   Project Status: implemented

Industry: Grains and fodder
Location: Atherton Tablelands
Pump Type: Centrifugal
Irrigation Type: Centre Pivot
Technology: Irrigation and Pumps, Tariffs, Solar Power and Renewables, Variable Speed Drives

The farm produces around 7,000t of hay over 41 hectares, with most of the energy used for irrigation. The annual energy consumption for the site during the 2018-2019 period was 63,642kWh at a cost of $14,052. 

The energy audit identified several opportunities to reduce energy consumption and cut costs, including:

  • Installing a 40kW solar system with a 30kW inverter to cover baseload power with possible export.
  • Installing an automated control system with an SMS alert in the pump station, with a capital cost of $3,500.
  • A change in strategy to day-time pumping using energy produced from solar onsite, with a shift to Tariff 20.
RecommendationSystem CostEnergy Savings T62 (kWh)Energy Savings T20 (kWh)Cost Savings T62 ($)Cost Savings T20 ($)Payback period T62 (Years)Payback Period T20 (Years)Emission Savings T62 (tCO2-e)Emission Savings T20 (tCO2-e)
40kW Solar PV40,0003,99946,6561,85112,539213.23.237.3

 

As the audit progressed, the farmer was keen to ensure that she, the auditor, the pump shop and electrician worked through how the solar system, irrigation pump, variable speed drive, tariff and operating strategy would work together. This helped make sure the audit recommendations became an integrated farm energy project. 

The 39.6 kW Solar array with 30kW inverter capacity has been arranged in an East-West configuration. As the irrigators run for long periods, the panels facing East will get to maximum capacity earlier in the morning, and the panels facing West will produce maximum power in the afternoon, providing constant supply throughout the day.

As the inverter capacity is no larger than 30kW, the system was treated as a micro embedded generating unit keeping the connection process simple and meaning the farm can still export during times of no irrigation. Maintaining grid connection allows the irrigator to draw grid power when required.

The auditor recommended that the farm move to a flat rate Tariff 20 and shift pumping to daylight hours while the solar PV system produces enough energy. Implementation of solar PV will absorb the increased tariff rate and any potential price increases in the future, reducing the overall energy costs and consumption.

The farmer has implemented the Solar PV system and a Variable Speed Drive to reduce the speed of the motors due to high pressure delivered by the pump, causing leakages in the pivot system. The farmer has also switched to tariff 20. Further, ‘time’ efficiency measures have been achieved using automation on the centre pivot. With the main farmhouse around 10 minutes from the irrigator, regular drives are required to start and stop its operation. Additionally, the automation will reduce fuel usage and allow time to be better spent on the crop. Should the centre pivot stop working, an SMS is sent to a mobile device alerting the operator.

The benefits extended beyond energy and cost savings. In a later conversation, the farmer explained that the creek pump had previously required manual operation and was a few minutes’ drive from the house. When her husband was away, this sometimes meant taking her daughter with her to operate the pump, including at night, rather than leaving her at home. Remote operation from a phone removed that need. For the farmer, the automation provided an important practical and family benefit alongside the energy and labour savings.

What did M&V find?

M&V confirmed that the project delivered substantial savings. However, it also showed that the way the farm operated the new system affected the value being captured from the solar investment.

Only 41% of solar generation was being used onsite, while 42,504 kWh was exported to the grid. At the same time, the farm was still importing 30,676 kWh from the grid. This meant there was an opportunity to make better use of the solar system by aligning more irrigation with solar-generation periods. 

The savings made have been measured in a Measurement and Verification (M&V) process, as outlined in Table 2.

Table 2. Estimated and Actual annual energy and cost savings.

MetricAudit estimationM&V calculationVariation (%)
Energy Savings including exports (kWh) 46,65672,26055
Cost Savings including exports revenue ($)12,5399,815-22

 

The lower cost savings measured compared to the estimated have been affected by the high amount of energy exported to the grid and the low 2020 feed-in tariff. Only 29,756 kWh or 41% of total generation are being used onsite valued at $6,474, and 42,504 kWh are being exported to the grid with a revenue of $3,341. Considering that 30,676 kWh – 52% of the total energy used onsite – are being imported from the grid at a cost of $6,674, there are significant potential savings from shifting consumption into the solar generation period. The total power balance of the farm, including solar exports and the energy cost distribution, are shown in the following figures.

Energy ES195

Cost ES195

M&V identified the next opportunity

Verification did not simply confirm the savings already achieved. It identified an opportunity to capture extra savings from the investment.

The M&V found that shifting more irrigation into solar-generation periods could reduce grid purchases and increase solar self-consumption. It estimated that shifting 30,676 kWh of annual consumption to coincide with solar generation could deliver a further $4,263 per year in savings. 

Solar optimisation ES195

By implementing the recommendations in the audit, the farm has reduced energy consumption by 113%, including the energy exported to the grid, and costs by 70%, including feed-in revenue, with Carbon emission savings of 57.6 tCO2-e per year.

Table 3. Pre and post implementation energy, costs, and energy productivity improvements.

MetricPre-implementationPost-implementationReduction (%)
Energy Consumption (kWh)63,642-8,618113
Cost ($)14,0524,23770
Energy Productivity (kWh/ton)9.1-1.2113

 

The accuracy of the recommendations in the audit, coupled with the specialist electrician’s advice, provided the best possible outcome for the farm. Energy consumption from the grid could be further reduced by matching pump use with solar generation.

From audit to ongoing improvement

This case study demonstrates the value of treating an energy audit as the beginning of an improvement process rather than the end of one. The audit identified several opportunities, implementation support helped bring those measures together into a practical project, and M&V confirmed the result while identifying where additional savings could still be captured.

Understand the system. Support implementation. Verify the outcome. Then use what has been learned to identify the next opportunity. 

An energy audit is a great way for a business to cut costs and boost productivity. 

The Energy Savers Plus Extension Program was delivered by the Queensland Farmers' Federation with support and funding from the Queensland Department of Energy and Public Works.

Capture

Back to case studies

Support opportunities for your farm.


A number of initiatives are available for Queensland farms and landholders wishing to find and adopt energy saving initiatives for their farm.

 

Learn more